Goodfellas Pizza Shack

1413 Bronx River Ave, Bronx, NY 10472 Order nowView full menu
Hero image

Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Goodfellas Pizza Shack Reviews on Grubhub


Top Reviewer
One of the best family deluxe pizza order I ever had in the Bronx. The cheese on the pizza was so cheesy, the wings were on point and toppings on the pizza was fresh. The order came 2 hours later than what it was suppose to come, but the customer service was excellent and they gave us French fries, cheesy garlic bread and pepperoni garlic knots on top of the other things we ordered. They were apologetic about everything. I'll definitely order here again.


3 reviews
We ordered a custom pizza. It was delicious and arrived hot! Very unusual for a pizza delivery. The sauce was not salty and the crust was deliciuos. There are other items on the menu that I would like to try. I will definitely order from them again.


Top Reviewer
Pizza was great and not greasy like most places. Mozzarella sticks tasted homemade and the honey bbq wings were amazing. I would definitely recommend this place.


Top Reviewer
Food was great, really delicious, fast delivery, driver was super friendly, forgot one of my sodas but minor detail, no biggie, will definitely order again!


1 review
The food is great. This was my third time eating from here. And the drivers and in store staff are very friendly. Best pizza i've had in years.

Reviews from

Goodfellas Pizza Shack Reviews on Seamless


Top Reviewer
So far I've tried their Pizza and Sicilian pies both were very good their Honey BBQ & Lemon Pepper Wings tasty will be ordering from Goodfellas on Fridays it will be my "go to spot"


3 reviews
I love their food and the employees are very nice and professional.
I recommend their food to everyone its a must try


2 reviews
Fast, friendly, huge portions, and reasonable prices. One of the best eggplant parm I ever had. Highly recomended


Top Reviewer
This place is awesome. Thanks for bringing good food to the neighborhood.


3 reviews
Food came on time, it want bangin.

About us

Calzones, Dinner, Italian, Lunch Specials, Pasta, Pizza, Salads
Delivery: 12:00 PM - 8:30 PM
Takeout: 12:00 PM - 8:30 PM